Once a warrant is involved, companies are legally required to comply with the access request and while many have tried to fight this with end-to-end encryption and removing user data from their servers, the overall tech community generally does follow the warrant orders. While many users are okay with warranted access, the emergency access that Amazon and Google are offering has little in terms of limits and description on what is an “emergency”.
However, it should be noted that other big tech companies have made public statements stating that they will not release user information without a warrant, but most of them have at some point allowed access to their users’ data without such a warrant. With Apple allowing emergency access in the past and Anker’s “end-to-end” video encryption being leaked from their servers.
The concern to these requests is that groups have found many ways to basically use these emergency requests to access user data illegally. Both Apple and Meta (Facebook) have not only fallen for these attacks, but the attackers were able to successfully access the private data they requested. We recommend running a self-hosted security system if you do not want big tech accessing your household and you can check out our forums for user help if need be.